Media Bias

Never a successful Civilian defensive gun use on NBC: Woman fails to use a gun to protect herself

4 Feb , 2021   Video

NBC’s Chicago PD has a long history of trying to convince people that they shouldn’t try to use a gun defensively. When gang members threatened a civilian, the police tried to convince him to leave his gun at home (Season 5, Episode 13, 2018). When he doesn’t, it results in him getting murdered. Another episode from Chicago PD has a man carrying a concealed handgun that he uses to stop his car from being carjacked (Season 7 Episode 11, January 15, 2020). His child and wife were in the car when the attempted carjacking occurred. But, despite the man’s wife clearly warning her husband that a police officer had arrived on the scene, the civilian points his gun at the officer, and the husband almost gets shot. His action also puts the officer’s life in danger.

This latest episode pushes a common Michael Bloomberg theme on women and guns (Chicago PD S8 E4, January 27, 2021). A woman tries to use a gun to stop an abusive boyfriend from hurting her, but he takes the gun from her and beats her. The boyfriend then uses the gun that he stole from her to murder a police officer. There is no notion that if a much physically stronger male attacker is close enough to the woman to take her gun, the woman is already in extreme danger.

Here is a discussion from “More Guns, Less Crime” (University of Chicago Press, 2010, p. 66):

“The effect of gun ownership by women deserves a special comment. Despite the relatively small number of women who obtain concealed- handgun permits, the concealed-handgun coefficient for explaining rapes in the first three sets of results is consistently similar in size to the effect that this variable has on other violent crime. January 1996 data for Washington and Oregon reveal that women constituted 18.6 and 22.9 percent, respectively, of those with concealed-handgun permits. The set of women who were the most likely targets of rape probably chose to carry concealed handguns at much higher rates than women in general. The preceding results show that rapists are particularly deterred by handguns. As men- tioned earlier, the National Crime Victimization Survey data show that providing a woman with a gun has a much greater effect on her ability to defend herself against a crime than providing a gun to a man. Thus even if few women carry handguns, the change in the “cost” of attacking women could still be as great as the change in the “cost” of attacking men, despite the much higher number of men who are becoming armed. To phrase this differently, if one more woman carries a handgun, the extra protection for women in general is greater than the extra protection for men if one more man carries a handgun.”

Or on page 4:

“While resistance is generally associated with higher probabilities of serious injury to the victim, not all types of resistance are equally risky. By examining the data provided from 1979 to 1987 by the Department of Justice’s National Crime Victimization Survey, Lawrence Southwick, confirming earlier estimates by Gary Kleck, found that the probability of serious injury from an attack is 2.5 times greater for women offering no resistance than for women resisting with a gun. In contrast, the probability of women being seriously injured was almost 4 times greater when resisting without a gun than when resisting with a gun. In other words, the best advice is to resist with a gun, but if no gun is available, it is better to offer no resistance than to fight.”

, , ,

By



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *