CPRC on National Public Radio: Trying to discuss the problems with the Gun Violence Archive

28 Apr , 2016

National Public Radio did a report on the Gun Violence Archive, which collects cases of gun deaths and crimes. But there is a reason we should rely on FBI and CDC data before we rely on what Bryant has put together. You simply can’t use media reports to determine what happened in cases. The FBI and CDC also has national standards that allow you to make sure that you are putting together similar cases.

The discussion on this show of defensive gun uses is not very useful. NPR had Bryant make his point first, a partial discussion by John Lott, and then Bryant’s response. Lott’s point wasn’t that all these cases aren’t reported to anyone. Some aren’t, but what Lott had argued during the part of the interview that was edited out was two fold:

1) Media reports rarely cover cases where people use guns defensively. If someone uses a gun defensively and the criminal runs away (as occurs in virtually all defensive gun uses), that is simply not going to be considered newsworthy even if it is reported to the newspaper. If you believe media accounts actually get virtually all the defensive gun uses, you would have to believe that about 85% of the defensive gun uses end in the criminal being killed. No one believes that. It is just that those cases are more newsworthy than cases where the criminal is wounded. Only a few percent of the cases seem to involve cases where no one is harmed.

2) There is no standard reporting for police even when they are told about DGUs. There are no reporting forms for police. Police do not report these cases to the FBI. Justifiable homicides are in theory reported by the police to the FBI, but that data for civilians is even worse than it is for the police, and I suspect you have heard how horribly bad the police data is.

Bryant was inaccurate when he claimed that Lott said that concealed handgun laws in Chicago were responsible for the drop in violent crime after the law being in effect for just a month. In fact, after the law had been in effect for a year-and-a-half Lott said “it is very doubtful that permitted concealed could have a significant impact on crime rates.”

media appearance, media bias on guns

By johnrlott

2 Responses

Bartosh Rudnicki says:

April 28, 2016 at 2:36 PM

“Sixty-two percent of Americans are dissatisfied with the nation’s laws or policies on guns, the highest percentage dissatisfied since 2001.

Based on answers to a follow-up question, those who are dissatisfied with gun laws are much more likely to say they want these laws to be stricter. Overall, 38% of Americans are dissatisfied with the nation’s gun laws and want them made stricter, 15% are dissatisfied and want the laws made less strict, and 9% are dissatisfied but say laws should remain as they are.”

http://www.gallup.com/poll/188219/americans-dissatisfaction-gun-laws-new-high.aspx
- johnrlott says:
  
  April 28, 2016 at 2:45 PM
  
  Please explain what this comment has to do with this post. Other Gallup polls show a somewhat different relationship.
  
  https://crimeresearch.org/2013/12/polls-consistently-show-that-over-the-last-couple-decades-more-people-are-opposing-more-gun-control/
  
  See also.
  https://crimeresearch.org/2014/12/new-pew-survey-shows-that-support-for-gun-ownership-increasing-mirrors-other-surveys-showing-that-people-believe-guns-make-them-safer/

Comments are closed.

Comments RSS Feed

Crime Prevention Research Center

CPRC on National Public Radio: Trying to discuss the problems with the Gun Violence Archive

2 Responses

Books

Archives

Click here to subscribe to our research updates

UPDATED: Comparing Death Rates from Mass Public Shootings and Mass Public Violence in the US and Europe

Updated: Murder and homicide rates before and after gun bans

Comparing murder rates and gun ownership across countries

Murders in US very concentrated: 54% of US counties in 2014 had zero murders, 2% of counties have 51% of the murders

At Real Clear Investigations: There Are Far More Defensive Gun Uses Than Murders in America. Here’s Why You Rarely Hear of Them.

On Armed American Radio: What Democrats may be hiding in the anti-gun amendments in upcoming budget bills

On the Michigan Talk Network: Vote Fraud Problems with Mail-in Ballots

A review of Pennsylvania and Nevada show that tens of thousands more votes were counted than people who were officially recorded as voting

Search by Topic