At Real Clear Investigations: Gun Safety: Armed Teachers Offers Students Best Protection

Nov 19, 2026 | Gun Free Zones, Original Research

Dr. John Lott has a new piece at Real Clear Investigations. The graphs are shown at the end of the piece.

.

The murder of 26 children and staff members at Sandy Hook Elementary School in 2012 ignited one of America’s most consequential debates about guns and school safety. As anti-firearm activists argued for expanded gun-free zones, 20 states moved in the opposite direction, passing laws to allow qualified teachers and other adults to bring guns to school.

.

Gun violence has surged at schools in the years since. From 2013–2025, the annual average number of deaths increased by 169%, compared to the period 2000 through 2102. Excluding suicides and gang-related attacks, the increase reached 214%. 

.

Graph 1 go here

But the vast majority of that violence has occurred at schools with no armed presence, according to a new report from the Crime Prevention Research Center, which I head. Almost none happened at schools that allow teachers or other nonuniformed employees to carry firearms.

.

“So much of the gun control debate is over things that might possibly go wrong, but with all the schools that have allowed teachers and staff to carry concealed over many decades, we don’t have to guess,” said Professor Carl Moody, a crime researcher at the College of William & Mary. 

.

There were 914 school shootings from 2013 through 2025, 518 of which resulted in a death or injury. These incidents ranged from a gun being accidentally fired to gang-related violence to a mass public shooting. Fifty-nine involved suicide-only incidents, including attempts. A total of 265 people died and 674 were wounded or injured, including certain attacker casualties but excluding deaths and injuries resulting from suicide attempts. That comes to 20.4 deaths and 51.8 injuries a year. Over those 13 years, enrolled averaged 55.5 million students at the nation’s roughly 99,000 K-12 schools.

.

The CPRC study found that for the even longer period stretching from 2000 through 2025, no deaths or injuries from shooting attacks during or near classroom hours were reported at schools that permit authorized teachers and non-uniformed staff to carry firearms. Currently, 13,156 schools across 28 states allow authorized adults to carry firearms.

.

Figures 1 and 2 go here

Over that same period, there were 39 attacks that produced casualties other than the attacker at the 44,000 public schools that use law enforcement or other uniformed armed guards for protection. In addition, officers accidentally discharged their firearms in 20 times, with additional incidents involving struggles or private guards. In three cases, officers shot someone other than the intended target or a bystander they misidentified, all at schools where state law banned teachers and permit holders from carrying. 

.

The greatest number of incidents, by far, occurred at schools with neither officers nor armed teachers: 551 between 2000-2025. Armed officers protect about 44.5% of schools, while 42.2% have neither officers nor armed teachers. Adjusting for these shares, schools without either form of armed protection experienced attacks involving casualties at 14.9 times the rate of schools with armed officers.

.

Figures 3 and 4 go here

The intention to avoid places where people can stop them with lethal force is a recurring theme in the writings of mass shooters. “I recently heard a rumor that James Holmes, the Aurora theater shooter, may have chosen venues that were ‘gun-free zones,’ the shooter at Minneapolis’ Annunciation Catholic School wrote before the August 2025 attack. “I would probably aim the same way. . . . Holmes wanted to make sure his victims would be unarmed. That’s why I and many others like schools so much. At least for me, I am focused on them. Adam Lanza is my reason.” (Lanza committed the mass shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown, Connecticut.) 

.

This shooter even explained why he avoided attacking during morning drop-off or afternoon pickup, when parents with concealed-carry permits might be present.

.

The Nashville Covenant School shooter wrote in 2023 that  she avoided another target because people carried guns there. “There was another location that was mentioned, but because of a threat assessment by the suspect of too much security, they decided not to,” Nashville Police Chief John Drake explained. 

.

The relative safety of schools allowing nonuniformed adults to carry guns versus those with armed guards suggests a broader public safety pattern. Crime research shows that attackers often target uniformed officers first to remove the primary threat to their plans.

.

“Even when police or deputies are in the right place at the right time, those in uniform who can be readily identified as guards may as well be holding up neon signs saying, ‘Shoot me first,’” said Sarasota (Florida) County Sheriff Kurt Hoffman. “They can [also] wait for a deputy to leave the area or pick an undefended location.”

.

Broader active-shooter data from 2014 through 2025, drawn from FBI definitions of incidents in which someone is actively killing or attempting to kill people in a populated public area, further illustrate both of the sheriff’s points. In part because active shooters will tend to avoid targets when they see uniformed officers, of the 615 cases, legally armed civilians stopped 36.6% of attacks overall and 52.9% in places where civilians could legally carry. Police stopped 29.1%. 

.

The data also show the danger facing those in uniform. Even though police stopped fewer attacks, the attackers killed 31 officers and injured 110, compared with two armed civilians killed and 55 injured. In the 225 cases where armed civilians stopped attacks, none shot the wrong person or obstructed police, and an attacker seized a civilian’s gun in only one instance.

.

The presence of non-uniformed gun holders may deter attacks because the would-be perpetrator does not know who might offer lethal resistance. On May 21, 2021, for example, a teacher at Lincoln Elementary School in Ogden confronted a 41-year-old man who tried to kidnap an 11-year-old girl on the school playground. The girl broke free and ran into the school. The man chased her and tried to force his way inside. The teacher, who held a concealed carry permit, drew his firearm and held the man at gunpoint until police arrived.

.

The safety of schools with armed teachers and other nonuniformed adults undermines many of the arguments made against the initiatives. Legislative debates over allowing teachers to carry are filled with concerns about what might go wrong. “Teachers and coaches have bad days too. Principals have bad days as well,” Mississippi state Rep. David Myers (D-McComb) when he warned that they could get angry or lose control and shoot someone. 

.

“The risk is losing an armed teacher to law enforcement who will struggle to identify the good guy with a gun versus the bad guy with a gun,” Iowa state Rep. Beth Wessel-Kroeschell (D-Ames) said. “The risk is accidentally leaving the weapon in the restroom, locker room, unlocked desk drawer and a young, curious student finding it.” 

.

Ohio Democratic state Rep. Phil Robinson expressed concern about “escalated situations and accidental shootings.”

.

A few accidents have occurred during firearm training classes held on school property outside of school hours. But the CPRC report shows there has never been a case of a teacher accidentally shooting someone or doing so in rage. Nor has a student ever gained possession of a teacher’s or school staffer’s gun and harmed anyone. Nor has an officer accidentally shot an armed teacher.

.

“The fear that the presence of guns increases violence is simply not born out regarding school safety,” David Mustard, a co-author of the CPRC report and a distinguished professor at the University of Georgia who researches crime extensively, told RCI. “With over 13,000 public schools having armed teachers and staff, many over decades, the report has the striking finding that schools with armed teachers are the safest, followed by schools with armed officers, and by far the most dangerous are schools with no armed protection.”

.

One measure of the risk of allowing teachers and staff to carry is what happens to insurance premiums. School insurance rates are no higher for schools that allow teachers to carry. “Utah has allowed permit holders to carry on school grounds since 2003, but in all my years in the insurance business since then, there has never been a general rate increase in liability insurance, either personal or business, including premiums for schools attributed to guns in schools,” said Curt Oda, former president of the Utah Association of Independent Insurance Agents. A survey of schools in Arkansas, Kansas, Ohio, South Dakota, and Texas also did not indicate that teacher carry had caused an increase in insurance premiums. Insurance fees significantly declined in Kansas.

.

The report also raises financial questions about school security. Using South Carolina as an example, it estimates combined state and local spending on school resource officers at approximately $108 million for the 2026-27 school year, excluding one-time equipment and training costs.

.

Public opinion provides another element of the debate. A McLaughlin & Associates survey of 1,000 general election voters, commissioned by the Crime Prevention Research Center and conducted Aug. 25, 2026, found 51.4% supported allowing teachers to carry concealed handguns, while 35.7% opposed it. Among voters with children in K–12 schools, support reached 57.3%, compared with 30.2% opposition.

.

Gun control groups – Everytown, Gun Violence Archive, Brady United, and Giffords Law Center – declined repeated requests to respond to the findings in the report.

.

“People assume gun bans make places safer, but these laws mainly signal to criminals that victims cannot fight back,” said Luis Locay, an associate professor at the University of Miami who has studied crime. “Penalties destroy the lives of otherwise law-abiding people who violate them, yet mean nothing to someone planning murder. They simply ensure that victims are defenseless.”

.

John R. Lott, Jr., “Gun Safety: Armed Teachers Offers Students Best Protection,” Real Clear Investigations, November 19, 2026.

Screenshot

johnrlott

0 Comments

Categories

Archives