The gap between what audiences think of a movie and what top movie critics think of a movie has rarely been larger than for Jennifer Garner’s “Peppermint,” except for notably Bruce Willis’ recent “Death Wish.” While only 13% of all critics (and 14% of top movie reviewers) liked “Peppermint,” there is a huge gape between that and the 85% of the audiences who saw it and liked it.
We have done some searching on the Rotten Tomatoes website, but few recent movies are even close to that 72% gap. Thankfully, the Guardian newspaper looked at 10,000 movies over the period from 1970 to 2013 also using the Rotten Tomatoes database. We found different numbers for one of the top movies that they ranked (Scary Movie 5 only had an audience score of 38 via Rotten Tomatoes). In any case, using their list to help us identify the movies with the largest gaps, Death Wish (2018) is ranked as tied for the 11th biggest gap between audience and all critics scores and tied for the second largest gap between audience and top critics scores.
Click on the ranking of movies to enlarge.
Our previous post on the political bias in the movie reviews for Bruce Willis’ movie is here.
Compare that to movies widely praised by critics such as Annihilation (86% of critics and 66% of the audiences like it), Foxtrot (98% of critics and 6% of audiences), Dance Academy (100% of critics and 80% of audiences), and Goldstone (80% of critics and 68% of audiences).