New Research on Red Flag Laws: Do they save lives? Reduce homicides or suicides?

Nov 22, 2019 | Gun Control Laws

Dr. John Lott and, our research director, Carlisle Moody have new research on the impact of Red Flag laws on homicides and suicides.

Abstract

Seventeen states have passed Red Flag or Extreme Risk Protection Order (ERPO) laws which allow police, family members, individuals living in the same residence, and others to file a petition for a court order temporarily seizing the firearms of persons accused to be a danger to themselves or others. The theory is that some individuals could pose a danger to themselves and others that could be made worse by the presence of firearms. Therefore, a policy that denied the individual access to their firearms, if only temporarily, might indeed save lives. However, it is possible that these laws could increase homicide or suicide. If a troubled person is aware of the existence of a Red Flag law, he or she may well not seek help because of the threat of an ERPO. Also, the enforcement of the orders could also have perverse consequences.

Two states have considerable experience with ERPO’s: Connecticut, since1999, and Indiana since 2005. We use synthetic controls and difference in differences methods to evaluate these laws. The experience in both Connecticut and Indiana is that red flag laws have had no significant effect on either homicide or suicide. We also find that ERPO laws have had no significant effect on deaths or injuries from mass public shootings.


(Visited 80 times, 1 visits today)

johnrlott

0 Comments

Archives

Police waited outside Robb Elementary School for 56 minutes before Border Patrol Tactical Unit entered the school, it took 14 minutes for the police to arrive. Total time before law enforcement entered the school after first call is 70 minutes.

Police waited outside Robb Elementary School for 56 minutes before Border Patrol Tactical Unit entered the school, it took 14 minutes for the police to arrive. Total time before law enforcement entered the school after first call is 70 minutes.

While 19 children and two teachers were being murdered inside the Robb Elementary School in Uvalde, police waited outside the school trying to decide what to do. Eventually it wasn't the police who entered, but a Border Patrol Tactical Unit. The murderer also...